Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Aksara Community
Journal of Engagement, Empowerment and Impact
 

Aksara Community uses an independent peer-review process to assess scientific quality, methodological rigor, ethical conduct, relevance, originality, clarity, and evidence of meaningful community impact.

1. Initial Editorial Screening

Submissions are screened for scope, completeness, originality, ethical requirements, methodological adequacy, and basic reporting quality. Purely descriptive activity reports without meaningful evaluation may be declined without external review.

2. Peer Review Model

Manuscripts that pass screening are normally evaluated by at least three independent reviewers. Aksara Community applies a double-anonymized peer-review model whenever practicable.

3. Reviewer Selection

Reviewers are selected for subject, methodological, or implementation expertise, independence, availability, and absence of significant conflicts of interest.

4. Editorial Decisions

Possible decisions include accept, minor revision, major revision, resubmit for review, or decline. Reviewer recommendations inform but do not determine the final editorial decision.

5. Revisions

Authors invited to revise must respond point by point to editorial and reviewer comments and clearly identify manuscript changes.

6. Community-Relevance Assessment

Reviewers may consider whether the manuscript clearly defines community needs, describes engagement or intervention processes, provides appropriate evaluation, reports measurable outcomes, and discusses sustainability, transferability, and limitations.

7. Confidentiality and AI

Reviewers and editors must maintain confidentiality and may not upload confidential manuscripts to public AI systems where confidentiality cannot be assured.

8. Editor or Board-Member Submissions

Submissions from editors or editorial-board members are handled independently by another qualified editor without a relevant conflict of interest.

Last updated: September 2026