User Menu
Peer-Review Process
Peer Review Process
Journal of Equity and Innovation in Resource-Limited Settings
Aksara Health uses an independent peer-review process designed to evaluate scientific quality, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, originality, relevance, and clarity while protecting confidentiality and editorial independence.
1. Initial Editorial Screening
All submissions are first screened by the editorial office for scope, completeness, basic methodological adequacy, ethical requirements, plagiarism or problematic overlap, and compliance with journal policies. Manuscripts that clearly fall outside the journal scope or fail fundamental scientific or ethical requirements may be declined without external review.
2. Peer Review Model
Manuscripts that pass initial screening are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Aksara Health applies a double-anonymized peer-review model whenever practicable: reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors and author-identifying information should be removed from the review version where feasible.
3. Reviewer Selection
Reviewers are selected on the basis of subject expertise, methodological competence, independence, availability, and absence of relevant competing interests. Authors may suggest reviewers, but the journal is not obliged to use suggested reviewers. Editors retain full responsibility for reviewer selection.
4. Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers must provide objective, constructive, evidence-based comments; maintain manuscript confidentiality; disclose conflicts of interest; avoid inappropriate citation requests; and refrain from using unpublished information for personal or professional advantage.
5. Editorial Decisions
Possible decisions include accept, minor revision, major revision, resubmit for review, or decline. Editorial decisions are based on the manuscript as a whole and are not determined solely by reviewer votes. The handling editor and Editor-in-Chief retain responsibility for the final decision.
6. Revisions
Authors invited to revise should respond systematically to reviewer and editor comments and clearly identify manuscript changes. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or assessed editorially depending on the extent and nature of revision.
7. Confidentiality and AI
Submitted manuscripts are confidential scholarly communications. Editors and reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or substantial unpublished content to public AI systems where confidentiality cannot be assured. Any permitted use of AI-assisted tools must follow the journal's AI Policy.
8. Editor or Board-Member Submissions
Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, or individuals closely associated with the journal are handled by an independent editor who has no relevant conflict of interest. The submitting editor or board member has no role in reviewer selection, review, or the final decision.
9. Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they identify a substantive scientific or procedural concern. Appeals must be reasoned and evidence-based and will normally be assessed by an editor not directly responsible for the original decision.
Editorial independence: Acceptance or rejection is based on scientific and ethical merit and is not influenced by payment of publication charges, institutional status, nationality, or commercial considerations.